If you can’t get over Should I Marry a Murderer?, watch these twisted true crime shows next

If Should I Marry a Murderer? pulled you in with its unsettling mix of romance, deception, and real-life crime, you’re not alone. True crime stories that explore toxic relationships and hidden killers have become some of the most gripping content on streaming platforms. Here are some similar shows that dive into manipulation, murder, and psychological twists you won’t forget easily.

I Am a Killer (Netflix)

This chilling docuseries gives convicted murderers the spotlight as they recount their crimes in their own words. Each episode explores not just what they did, but why they did it. The show focuses heavily on psychology, trauma, and moral ambiguity, making it both disturbing and thought-provoking.

Conversations with a Killer: The Ted Bundy Tapes (Netflix)

One of the most iconic true crime series, this show uses archival audio recordings of Ted Bundy to explore how a seemingly charming man hid horrific crimes. It reveals how manipulation and charisma can mask true danger, especially in personal relationships and public perception.

The Puppet Master: Hunting the Ultimate Conman (Netflix)

This series follows a master manipulator who faked identities and emotionally destroyed multiple lives. It focuses on psychological control, trust, and betrayal, making it ideal for viewers interested in relationship-based crime stories.

Why Did You Kill Me? (Netflix)

A heartbreaking and modern take on crime investigation, this docuseries follows a family using social media to track down the killers of their loved one. It highlights how grief, obsession, and technology intersect in today’s world of crime-solving.

American Murder: The Family Next Door (Netflix)

Told entirely through real footage, text messages, and social media posts, this documentary shows how a picture-perfect family life can hide a disturbing reality. It is one of the most immersive and unsettling crime documentaries available.

The Tinder Swindler (Netflix)

While not a murder story, this documentary fits the same psychological space. It follows a conman who used dating apps to manipulate women emotionally and financially, showing how trust can be exploited in modern relationships.

Worst Roommate Ever (Netflix)

This series highlights real-life cases where people unknowingly lived with dangerous individuals. From fraudsters to violent criminals, it shows how deception can exist within everyday shared living situations.

The Jinx: The Life and Deaths of Robert Durst (HBO)

A widely acclaimed true crime documentary, this series follows a wealthy real estate heir suspected of multiple murders. Its most famous moment comes when the subject appears to implicate himself during filming.

If Should I Marry a Murderer? hooked you, these shows deliver a similar blend of suspense, emotional manipulation, and real-life horror. Whether it’s toxic relationships, hidden identities, or psychological control, each series reinforces the idea that danger often hides behind familiarity and trust.