An Indiana developer proposed 32 homes on 23.63 acres near Crooked Lake, with 30 lots sharing a single access point; a November 16 appeals ruling upheld the county’s extra approval requirement after neighbours objected

1794957059 representative image


An Indiana developer proposed 32 homes on 23.63 acres near Crooked Lake, with 30 lots sharing a single access point; a November 16 appeals ruling upheld the county's extra approval requirement after neighbours objected
Representative Image (AI-generated)

A proposed residential development near an Indiana lake has become the centre of a legal dispute over how many homes can share a single point of access to the waterfront. The project, involving 32 residential lots across 23.63 acres near Crooked Lake, faced objections from neighbouring property owners who raised concerns about concentrating lake access for multiple households in one common area. The disagreement eventually reached the Indiana Court of Appeals, where the developer challenged an additional approval requirement imposed by the county’s planning authorities.In its November 16, 2026, decision in Steuben County, Indiana Plan Commission v. 3rd Basin, LLC, available on Justia, the Court of Appeals reversed a lower court ruling that had favoured the developer. The appellate court concluded that the Steuben County Plan Commission was justified in requiring the developer to obtain a special exception for the proposed common-use lake access area before proceeding with the subdivision approval process. The decision centred on local zoning requirements intended to prevent excessive concentration of waterfront access through narrow entry points.

A 32-lot subdivision proposed near Crooked Lake

The developer, 3rd Basin LLC, owns a 23.63-acre property in Steuben County, Indiana, classified under the Lake Residential zoning district. It proposed dividing the land into 32 residential lots under a project named Shores of Crooked Lake. Under the preliminary plan, only two lots would have direct access to the lake. The remaining 30 would share a common waterfront area, identified as Common Area A, with a proposed large pier providing access to Crooked Lake.The arrangement became a major point of disagreement because it concentrated lake access for numerous residences through a single location. Several neighbouring property owners objected to the proposal, arguing that the arrangement raised concerns covered by the county’s anti-funnelling provisions. These provisions are intended to prevent multiple residences from relying on narrow waterfront access points. They also seek to maintain a reasonable relationship between the number of residents using a shoreline and the amount of waterfront available to them.

County required an additional special exception

In March 2025, 3rd Basin submitted its application for primary approval of the preliminary subdivision plat to the Steuben County Plan Commission. During an April 2 hearing, the issue of shared lake access and the proposed common dock was raised. The commission granted primary approval but made it conditional on the developer obtaining a special exception for the common-use dock from the Board of Zoning Appeals. This additional approval was required under the county’s zoning ordinance governing common-use lake access lots in Lake Residential districts.The developer challenged the condition, arguing that the commission had exceeded its authority under Indiana’s subdivision approval laws. It maintained that the statute limited the conditions that could be imposed at the primary approval stage and that the additional requirement was not among them. A Steuben County trial court agreed with the developer. It concluded that the commission had acted beyond its statutory authority after finding that the preliminary plat complied with the applicable subdivision improvement standards. The court directed the commission to remove the special exception condition from its approval findings. The Plan Commission and several neighbouring property owners appealed that decision.

Why the Indiana appeals court reversed the lower court

The Court of Appeals focused on Indiana Code Section 36-7-4-702, particularly the provision requiring proposed subdivision plats to comply with applicable zoning standards. The justices explained that although a planning commission may waive certain subdivision control standards, it cannot waive applicable zoning requirements unless those requirements have already been modified through a variance.The county’s zoning ordinance specifically required special exception approval for common-use lake access lots. Since Common Area A was intended to provide shared waterfront access to almost all the proposed residential lots, the requirement applied to the development. The court also rejected the developer’s argument that removing the proposed dock would eliminate the need for the special exception. It explained that the common waterfront access area itself remained subject to the anti-funnelling provisions, regardless of whether a dock was constructed.On November 16, 2026, the Indiana Court of Appeals reversed the trial court’s decision. The court concluded that the developer was required to obtain a special exception to comply with the county’s zoning standards before receiving primary approval of the subdivision plat. It also explained that, regardless of the timing of that requirement, the developer could not obtain secondary approval without the special exception. The ruling did not reject the entire residential development proposal, but upheld the county’s requirement that the developer satisfy its waterfront access zoning rules before advancing the project.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *